When James invites people who are (supposedly) wise and understanding to step forward and identify themselves, he is returning more explicitly to the topic of "teachers" addressed in 3:1. Especially for those who think they are wise enough to teach others, James wants his readers to know what true wisdom means. What he gives is more a description than a definition of wisdom. In fact, he has been describing it all along, with his talk of believing God, relying on God's goodness, doing what God's word says and living the righteous life that God desires. Now he will label this as wisdom and describe it further as a humble submissiveness to God which results in a life of goodness, purity and peace toward other people. To explain this, James analyzes three aspects of wisdom.
In regard to the nature of wisdom, first the impact of the question in 3:13 must be faced: Who is wise and understanding among you? For those who do not care about true wisdom but only want the status of being thought wise, the question is a challenge; James's answer will expose them for what they are. For those who honestly aspire to being wise, the question is an invitation; James's answer will divulge the way to attain their aspirations. James is saying, "I am about to tell you the nature of true wisdom; treasure this." Let all readers, then, first examine their own hearts before reading beyond the question posed in 3:13. Do you really want to be wise?
Then we must submit to James's answer about the requirement of true wisdom. Consistent with his previous instructions, James again requires actions that authenticate words. Who claims to be wise? Let him show it by his good life. Today the phrase good life has taken a connotation of a prosperous, pleasurable life. James, of course, is talking about quite another matter: moral goodness. His phrase is kales anastrophes, "good conduct" or "good behavior." He elaborates: Let him show it . . . by deeds. James is thinking with the same verb deiknymi and noun ergon as in 2:18; his point must be very close to that earlier verse. Genuine wisdom, like faith, is a practical matter; it shows up in how one lives. Literally James says, "Let him show by good behavior his deeds in the humility of wisdom." Wisdom, then, is not something I will merely possess in my head; if I am wise at all, it is something I will demonstrate in my conduct.
Finally, the personality of wisdom should be taken to heart: the wise deeds will be done in humility. Humility is the character trait underlying the Christian behavior described in the entire letter; this is the trait to cultivate if one would take James's teaching deeply into one's life. James would have approved of what Calvin wrote quoting Augustine, "When a certain rhetorician was asked what was the chief rule in eloquence, he replied, `Delivery'; what was the second rule, `Delivery'; what was the third rule, `Delivery'; so if you ask me concerning the precepts of the Christian religion, first, second, third, and always I would answer, `Humility' " (Institutes 2. 2. 11).
Therefore James's notion of humility is worth exploring. His term praytes is variously translated as "meekness" (KJV) and "gentleness" (NASB), but the NIV's "humility" is much to be preferred. "Meekness" today connotes a touch of weakness and passivity, which are not at all true in James's requirement of active obedience. "Gentleness" is appropriate in reference to our relationships with each other (and should be brought out in an exposition of 3:17-18); but James has a larger concept in mind as humility.
The terms prays and praytes ("humble" and "humility") do not occur in the Gospel of Mark, in Luke's Gospel or Acts, in Hebrews, or in the Johannine writings of the New Testament. This reflects the Christology of those writers, who place their emphasis on Christ as powerful Son and Lord. In Matthew the adjective prays is used three times, as a significant, characteristic trait of Jesus himself and of his followers. In Matthew 5:5, when Jesus pronounces the "meek" to be blessed, he is calling people to enter his kingdom with this stance of humility. In Matthew 11:29, Jesus invites people to come and learn from him specifically because he is himself "gentle." In Matthew 21:5, Matthew identifies Jesus as the "gentle" messianic king promised in Zechariah 9:9. Paul uses the noun praytes several times, notably as a fruit of the Spirit (Gal 5:23) and a trait of Christ (2 Cor 10:1) to be exhibited by all Christians toward other people (Eph 4:2; Col 3:12; Tit 3:2). This Christian virtue of humility is modeled after the ministry of Christ, who served others, sacrificed himself and placed himself wholly at the Father's disposal in perfect trust and obedience.
This seems to be very much James's own concept of humility, as observed in three applications within his letter. Humility is, first, the teachability by which we are to accept "humbly" the word of God in 1:21. But James emphasizes there that humbly accepting God's word entails doing the word. Therefore humility is, second, a submissive readiness to do what the word says with deeds done in . . . humility. Third, James shows in our current passage that in humility toward God we will become humble (and gentle) to live at peace with each other. The opposite of humility is an unwillingness to learn and a refusal to yield: the bitter envy and selfish ambition that will result in disorder. For James, humility is a yielding of oneself in ready teachability and responsiveness to God's word, resulting in a good and unselfish life of peace with other people.
Compare the two terms James employs when talking about humility. In 1:9-10 he used tapeinos to refer to the poor person's "humble circumstances" and tapeinosis to mention the rich person's reduction to a "low position." James used that term when thinking of circumstantial station in life. When speaking of the spiritual stance of teachability before God (as in 1:21 and here in 3:13), however, James uses praytes. Davids explains the awkwardness of the phrase "in the humility that comes from wisdom" as due to "a preference for the Semitic-influenced genitive construction" (1982:150). But the phrase is prompted by more than a grammatical preference. James is talking about a foundational element in a person of faith.
The problem James is addressing, then, is not that there are teachers spreading false doctrine (as would often be the concern in Paul's letters). James is addressing the problem of arrogance, which can be present even when correct doctrine is being taught. His warning should bring all teachers to an abrupt halt for self-examination. I can be correct in my doctrine down to the most esoteric details; I can attain a consistency in my orthodoxy which surpasses others'; I can gain a reputation for my thorough grasp of theology and be regarded as a protector of the faith; and my teaching may still be earthly, unspiritual, of the devil, resulting in disorder and every evil practice by stirring up suspicion, slander, distrust and contention within the Christian community.
James puts the critical issue to me: Am I teaching from humility or from selfish ambition? If it is the latter, then I am even failing in the matter about which I am most proud: my grasp of truth. For then my claim to be wise is itself a falsehood. That is the sense of James's conclusion, Do not boast about it or deny the truth.
The wisdom James wants his readers to seek is said to come from heaven (adverb anothen). The term can have a local sense ("from above") or a temporal sense ("from the beginning" or "for a long time"), and it is the term used in John 3 to describe being born "again" or born "anew." In the present passage, the local sense is indicated by the verb come down and by the contrast to the adjective earthly. This sense is also consistent with James's use of the same term in 1:17, where every good and perfect gift was stated to be from above and then explicitly from the Father. Wisdom is now declared to be one of those precious gifts that come from above.
But that divine origin makes the issue more important than mere location. James explains this by the series of three adjectives at the end of 3:15. The adjectives build upon each other in "an ascending scale of wickedness" (Mitton 1966:139). Earthly origin, in frequent New Testament usage, implies inferiority to heavenly origin. James then makes this more specific: bitter envy and selfish ambition are also unspiritual, denoting a natural source devoid of the supernatural Spirit of God. Finally, to leave no doubt about the evil source of the envy and ambition, James says they are literally demonic: of the devil. His investigation of false wisdom uncovers the same source as his investigation of the uncontrolled tongue in 3:6--they are both from hell. This is evidently the reason for the NIV's translation of anothen as from heaven in 3:15 and 3:17 rather than "from above" as in 1:17. James's intention is to point us to a wisdom from heaven in contrast to the wisdom from hell, a wisdom far superior to any wisdom we find in ourselves naturally, and certainly superior to that which comes from demons.
Since true wisdom comes from outside ourselves and from God himself, we have to examine where our reliance is placed. It makes sense of what James has already prescribed for a life of faith. It requires of us an active prayer life--to ask for wisdom as 1:5 commands. It requires a conscious dependence on God--in the humility prescribed in 3:13. True wisdom can be had only by people who live in active reliance on God.
Here James gives particular content to the deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. What will genuine wisdom look like in a person's life? James describes both the false wisdom and the true, and in each case he lists identifying attitudes and actions.
Regarding the false wisdom, we can understand why bitter envy and selfish ambition are the characteristic attitudes: they are the opposite of the humility entailed in admitting one's need and relying on God for the wisdom one lacks. The adjective pikros ("bitter") describes a harsh stance of demanding to be recognized as wise, instead of being willing to learn. The noun zelos ("envy") reveals the motivation as jealousy. The second noun, eritheia ("selfish ambition"), exposes the sinful desire for personal glory--wanting the status of a teacher so that others will have to learn from me. At this point it is valuable to remember that James has been addressing people who gather in Christian assemblies and who function as teachers in the church. His words shine a spotlight on the craving for self-glorification which moves even much of our work in "Christian ministry."
The resulting actions of false wisdom are also identified: disorder and every evil practice. James ever sees the connection between inward stance and outward practice. Genuine faith will manifest itself in deeds, and the same principle holds true in the contrasting demonic realm. The false wisdom that is of the devil will manifest itself in practices of disorder and evil. This is simply the application of the principle James learned from Jesus: by their fruit you will recognize them. When self-glorification is at the heart of Christian ministry by church members, those Christians will eventually become sowers of disorder, contention and other evil practices in the church.
Finally, the expression of true wisdom in the church is presented with the characteristic attitudes and resulting actions listed in 3:17-18. Three emphases stand out in the way James states this contrast with false wisdom.
First, in 3:17, James is deliberate to state a foremost characteristic of the wisdom from above: it is first of all pure and only then the other qualities. His term pure speaks of holiness and provides the immediate contrast to every evil practice. It reflects the high moral sensibility that we have found in James all along; he does not descend from it now. It is never a sentimental humanitarianism or an amoral pragmatism that motivates James; it isn't just that bitter envy hurts people or that selfish ambition does not work. The first and foremost reason for valuing wisdom is that it will lead people to do what is morally right. Today's popular relativism makes it all the more urgent that Christians learn James's passion for purity. Will we do what is wise first of all because it is right?
Second, in 3:17, James lists other attitudes and behavior of the wisdom from above. Peace-loving, considerate, submissive, full of mercy and good fruit, impartial and sincere fill out a picture of humility put into practice. The first three of these traits are terms that James uses only here in his letter; they describe people who can yield status, who care for others and who are willing to submit and learn from others--all in contrast to the bitterness, envy and selfish ambition of false spirituality. The remaining traits weave some of James's earlier instruction into this picture. Full of . . . good fruit is reminiscent of the recent imagery in 3:12. Full of mercy reminds James's readers of his urging to be merciful in 2:13. The terms for impartial and sincere are both built upon the root for judge (verb krino, noun krites)--an important concept already in the epistle.
Third, James summarizes in 3:18 (literally): "The fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace." This connects peacemaking and righteousness (cf. Jesus in Mt 5:9-10) and suddenly reveals why the disorder in 3:16 is so abhorrent to James. The opposite of the disorder is not a morally neutral order but a morally significant peace. James wants peace for the church because peace is the context in which righteousness can flourish. This is the positive side of what James said in 1:20, that human anger does not bring about the righteous life that God desires. Again, James writes out of a passion for righteousness.
Click the button below to continue.
Now that you've created a Bible Gateway account, upgrade to Bible Gateway Plus: the ultimate online Bible reading & study experience! Bible Gateway Plus equips you to answer the toughest questions about faith, God, and the Bible with access to a vast digital Bible study library. And it's all integrated seamlessly into your Bible Gateway experience. Try it free for 30 days!
Three easy steps to start your free trial subscription to Bible Gateway Plus.